Both my babies were delivered by c-section, and its a very calm relaxing experience, me and my partner were left to hold and meet our new arrival whilst i was stitched up then back on cds after the babys checks and mine we were brought drinks and snacks and left for alone time, i really cannot fault the experience at all, but i can completely understand your wifes dissapointment, as my family is now complete and ive never experienced a birth, i do feel as though ive missed out, but my babies are both happy and healthy and although my son was prem and in scbu for 56hrs the care was amazing and the section saved his life.
I also have a baby brother hes 4mnths he was induced due to size, mum was in labour for days with no progress she eventually gave in for a section and then missed out on being with him for 5hrs after he was born as the traumatic labour and then section caused her to heamorage and she was sent to recovery, thomas was 11lb 2oz! she now wishes shed just had a section! hes her 3rd and finall after that experience
i would say a compromise is the best option as if theres complications a hospital is the best place and there will be alot less stress on you your wife and baby if its just a matter of going into the OR instead of a mad dash to the hospital from home, best of luck to you all.