The Baxter are like true jeans whereas the Leugh are more stretchy. I guess it depends what you're comfy in. I like stiff skinnies so they don't 'fit' around knees / calf etc, and more go straight down in a straight line into a skinny ankle.
Try on and see what you think.
I have a selection of sizes as find the blue denim fits slightly differently to the black (black more stretch) so I think it depends on colour etc. Your best bet is te massive Topshop near your work at Oxford Circus!