Forgotten your password?
already a member?
Made For Mums
  •  
  • home
  • my neighbourhood
  • reviews
  • news + gossip
  • age + stage
  • feeding
  • win + offers
  • forum
  • sign up
what's on | groups & classes | local chat | places to go | childcare & schools | eating out | health | help | add listing
pushchairs & travel systems | car seats | feeding | cots & nursery | carriers & slings | all products
celebrities | hot stuff | pregnancy | baby | toddler + | mums & dads | it's amazing | fashion | MFM blog
getting pregnant | pregnancy & birth | your baby | your toddler+ | your schoolchild | your family
starting to wean | 7-9 mths | 9-12 mths | 12 mths+ | recipes | what to buy | fussy eaters | nutrition | food safety | special diets
competitions & giveaways
birth clubs | baby clubs | chat | your say! | 15 mins of fame | pregnancy | baby | parenting | potty training
forum
You are looking at: Home : Forum : Your say!

Talkback: Natalie Portman giving up Vegan beliefs for pregnancy

reply
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
Help | Settings | Public Profile
Related Article
Natalie Portman giving up vegan diet for pregnancy
Actress puts aside her vegan values for pregnancy dairy cravings
2 messages
Patrick Payne
12/04/2011 at 15:00
That's confused! She should be maintaining her vegan diet "for the baby!" Adding toxic meat and dairy to one's diet is not good for mother or baby. Obviously Natalie is just giving in to her taste cravings, which isn't wise. Meat and dairy are unhealthy any way you cut it.

Delicious cookies and cakes can be made without dairy. Yes, it's difficult to find them in "regular bakeries" but sweet desserts aren't that healthy when you're pregnant anyway.

Dr. Frank Oski, former director of pediatrics at Johns Hopkins University said, "There is no reason to drink cow's milk at any time in your life. It was designed for calves, it was not designed for humans, and we should all stop drinking it today, this afternoon."

Dr. Spock agreed, saying, "[T]here was a time when cow's milk was considered very desirable. But research, along with clinical experience, has forced doctors and nutritionists to rethink this recommendation."

The fact that there are entire cultures representing millions of people who have lived and thrived for centuries without meat and dairy is enough evidence that even pregnant humans do not "need" it to survive and thrive. In fact, the evidence weighs heavily in the other direction, i.e., the hazards of a meat and dairy diet and the benefits of a vegan diet are well known even for pregnant women and babies.

Natalie should control her cravings and make the effort to be healthy for her baby and that means continuing to omit meat and dairy.


Patrick Payne
Charmaine
13/04/2011 at 20:36
There are a lot of things humans do not "need" however they still indulge. A growing baby needs calcium etc, they say sometimes woman crave a certain substance when pregnant becuase its something they need, obvioulsy not unhealthy.....
Most websites tell you to eat these things in moderation, we are not born to be vegetarian or vegan.... I however did opt to be a vegetarian for many many years. ONce pregnant and after taking five years to become pregnant I did eat limited amounts of meat to ensure I didnt miss out nutritionally, I didnt want to risk anything. Most health professionals tell you to eat limited amounts of protein, carbs and then five a day, if she feels she needs this then why not.

I fully appreciate if people want to be pregnant or bfeeding and be vean or vegetarian, thats their choice as it her choice not to continue with her vegan ways whilst pregnant.
Charmaine
709 forum posts
22 photos
Your say
Terms and Conditions | Code of Conduct
email image
2 messages
Report this thread to the moderator

my events

Information
MadeForMums members can keep lists of upcoming events! Join us or Log in

most popular

  • Read
  • Latest
  1. 1
    Pregnant Katie Price angered after being "refused" sunbed session by salon
  2. 2
    Kim Kardashian has her baby early!
  3. 3
    Channing Tatum steals the show with baby pic
  4. 4
    Pregnant Caprice reveals she is expecting second child by surrogate mother
  5. 5
    Courtney Cox celebrates with lovely daughter
  1. 1
    Kanye West is ‘in love’ with his first child
  2. 2
    10 of the best lightweight buggies under 6kg
  3. 3
    Robbie Williams says fatherhood makes him happy
  4. 4
    Pregnant Katie Price angered after being "refused" sunbed session by salon
  5. 5
    Shakira celebrates her first Father’s Day with her family

question of the month poll

Did teething affect your baby during weaning?

discussions in my neighbourhood
What's the buzz in your area? Find out what everyone's talking about...
Buy, sell or find free family stuff
Meet up with other mums
Share what's going on in your community
Join in the chat about local classes
Find more in your neighbourhood

our top 5 buggy lists

10 celebrity buggies
10 best buggies under £150
10 of the best double buggies
10 of the best 3-wheelers
10 travel systems for under £400
See more travel systems and buggies
Follow MadeForMums on Twitter
Other Parenting sites:
  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting & Pregnancy
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums
  • BabyExpert
Other Immediate sites:
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • Visordown
  • Gardeners' World
  • RadioTimes
Become a fan on Facebook for exclusive content
Follow MadeForMums on Twitter
Subscribe to Practical Parenting & Pregnancy
Immediate Media Co
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookie policy
  • Terms + conditions
  • Advertise with us

© Immediate Media Company Ltd 2012. This website is owned and published by Immediate Media Company Limited. www.immediatemedia.co.uk

Version 2.8.53497.0