Forgotten your password?
already a member?
Made For Mums
  •  
  • home
  • my neighbourhood
  • reviews
  • news + gossip
  • age + stage
  • feeding
  • win + offers
  • forum
  • sign up
what's on | groups & classes | local chat | places to go | childcare & schools | eating out | health | help | add listing
pushchairs & travel systems | car seats | feeding | cots & nursery | carriers & slings | all products
celebrities | hot stuff | pregnancy | baby | toddler + | mums & dads | it's amazing | fashion | MFM blog
getting pregnant | pregnancy & birth | your baby | your toddler+ | your schoolchild | your family
starting to wean | 7-9 mths | 9-12 mths | 12 mths+ | recipes | what to buy | fussy eaters | nutrition | food safety | special diets
competitions & giveaways
birth clubs | baby clubs | chat | your say! | 15 mins of fame | pregnancy | baby | parenting | potty training
forum
You are looking at: Home : Forum : Your say!

Talkback: New book ‘blames’ mums for naughty children

reply
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
Help | Settings | Public Profile
Related Article
New book ‘blames’ mums for naughty children
Author and psychologist Oliver James suggests working mums and daycare are the cause of children’s bad behavior
3 messages
Claire Fuller
24/05/2010 at 16:20
I read a summary of this book in a Guardian interview. It's a desperate attempt for publicity by James; he needs to find an alternative 'cause' to take the moral highground. His arguments aren't backed up with any facts and he throws in sweeping statements to scare parents. He includes statistics but they don't even correlate with his ponints of view. It would be best if we all just ignored him.
Claire Fuller
Sarah Oswestry
25/05/2010 at 13:04
I think you're right that he might be selective with the research he quotes - but then I suppose most authors are, and if he sat on the fence he wouldn't produce a very thought provoking book.

But I'm not sure I agree with that 'a child needs sole care' theme. Lots of people quote the Swedish example, don't they, where it's really common for children to go to kindergarten. Or the example of big families, where the littlest children are left to their own devices and seem perfectly happy and balanced. I guess the difference can be love though, can't it. Some nurseries have it in abundance, and others maybe not, even though they're safe and efficient.

Can't wait for spring....
Sarah Oswestry
21 forum posts
Liz Hartley
27/05/2010 at 11:37
There is a huge gulf between the kind of care provided in Swedish nurseries and the average UK nursery. In effect, most children here in the UK are looked after by poorly-qualified nursery nurses, which is not the case in Sweden, where nurseries are staffed by highly-qualified, highly-trained staff. I sometimes wonder if parents ever take the time to look at the people who will actually be rearing their children while they're at work - I pass nurseries every day in the summer where the children are looking after themselves while their young nursery nurses sit on a wall together, chatting. High quality care? Individual attention?

As for the "big families" scenario, the point is that those children are at home within their extended family, not parked in nurseries and cared for by strangers. If the main carer is temporarily absent, the child is still contained within a familiar routine, with familiar patterns of behaviour and standards.

We do have choices after all - we don't need to have children. And for those who advocate ignoring the uncomfortable challenges of a book such as this, I'd say - don't ignore them. Reflect on them. If it makes us angry or uncomfortable, we should ask ourselves why.
Liz Hartley
Your say
Terms and Conditions | Code of Conduct
email image
3 messages
Report this thread to the moderator

my events

Information
MadeForMums members can keep lists of upcoming events! Join us or Log in

most popular

  • Read
  • Latest
  1. 1
    10 of the best lightweight buggies under 6kg
  2. 2
    10 of the most compact folding buggies
  3. 3
    The 10 best car seats - from 9 months
  4. 4
    Kate Middleton and Prince William hit The Baby Show at NEC, Birmingham?
  5. 5
    10 of the best buggies, as rated by you!
  1. 1
    Kate Middleton and Prince William hit The Baby Show at NEC, Birmingham?
  2. 2
    A new world of digital entertainment for children
  3. 3
    Annabel Karmel's Confetti Couscous Salad
  4. 4
    Annabel Karmel's Thai Prawn Kebabs
  5. 5
    Annabel Karmel's Teriyaki Chicken Burgers

question of the month poll

Which morning sickness remedy worked best for you?

discussions in my neighbourhood
What's the buzz in your area? Find out what everyone's talking about...
Buy, sell or find free family stuff
Meet up with other mums
Share what's going on in your community
Join in the chat about local classes
Find more in your neighbourhood

our top 5 buggy lists

10 celebrity buggies
10 best buggies under £150
10 of the best double buggies
10 of the best 3-wheelers
10 travel systems for under £400
See more travel systems and buggies
Follow MadeForMums on Twitter
Other Parenting sites:
  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting & Pregnancy
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums
  • BabyExpert
Other Immediate sites:
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • Visordown
  • Gardeners' World
  • RadioTimes
Become a fan on Facebook for exclusive content
Follow MadeForMums on Twitter
Subscribe to Practical Parenting & Pregnancy
Immediate Media Co
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookie policy
  • Terms + conditions
  • Advertise with us

© Immediate Media Company Ltd 2012. This website is owned and published by Immediate Media Company Limited. www.immediatemedia.co.uk

Version 2.8.52181.0